Professional wrestling is undergoing a renaissance. The top breakout stars in WWE and AEW are stepping into the spotlight, capturing interest from a wider audience than ever before. Both WWE and All Elite Wrestling have emerged as dynamic promotions that showcase seasoned veterans while introducing new talents who hunger for stardom. This flourishing environment has become fertile ground for ambitious athletes looking to make their mark. As 2025 begins, fans want to know who will define the next era of sports entertainment. This article explores the key figures who are primed for major breakthroughs, along with the trends and factors shaping their trajectories.
Though storylines and characters vary between WWE and AEW, many core elements of professional wrestling remain the same. Strong in-ring performances, compelling mic work, and crowd engagement are universal avenues for success. However, each promotion has its own flavor of storytelling, roster dynamics, and creative directives. This combination ensures that every rising star follows a distinct path. Some might become champion through consistent dominance, while others will capture the public’s imagination by showcasing resilience or underdog grit. When the timing is right, a spotlight moment can propel a mid-card prospect into the main event scene almost overnight.
Yet stardom in pro wrestling doesn’t solely hinge on in-ring talent. A breakout star also needs the creative team’s confidence, an ability to connect with fans across multiple platforms, and a well-timed storyline that highlights every facet of their persona. Consider how crowd reactions can become catalysts for greater opportunities. Chants, social media interactions, and merchandise sales all reflect a wrestler’s drawing power. In an era when promoters look at fan analytics, evidence of growing popularity can significantly influence who receives coveted matches and title shots. Thus, as we look forward to the rest of 2025, we must examine not only each performer’s ability but also the momentum generated by fan enthusiasm and backstage support.
The Concept of a Breakout Star
A breakout star transcends initial promise to become a consistent talking point among fans, commentators, and critics. They create buzz with every appearance, whether it’s through innovative moves, memorable promos, or emotional storytelling. They might achieve this by dethroning a popular champion, betraying an ally, or displaying an unexpected range of personality beyond the squared circle. This leap from mid-level relevance to top-tier status signals a special alchemy that many wrestlers strive for, yet only a select few truly achieve.
In the high-octane world of sports entertainment, the audience’s attention can be fickle. Certain performers keep fans invested by evolving, revealing new layers of their persona as each storyline unfolds. Meanwhile, others fall into repetition or fail to adapt when a fresh concept doesn’t land. The path to becoming a breakout star also depends on how well a talent navigates external factors, such as injuries, sudden booking changes, or the arrival of newly signed superstars who might steal the limelight. The wrestlers highlighted here have either shown resilience in overcoming obstacles or have demonstrated the raw potential needed to rise through the ranks if they stay healthy and remain dedicated to their craft.
Recent Success Stories
In recent years, several performers have illustrated the many ways one can ascend to stardom. Over in AEW, Mariah May emerged from the shadow of “Timeless” Toni Storm. At first, May was introduced as a starstruck devotee, almost an understudy to the champion. She then flipped that narrative by showcasing her own skill, defeating seasoned opponents, and taking center stage. When she eventually challenged Storm herself, she proved capable of carrying a compelling feud. That transformation demonstrates what happens when a performer runs with a storyline that allows them to grow beyond their initial role.
Jade Cargill, another AEW standout, spent her early career on a hot undefeated streak. Although new to the industry, she displayed a commanding presence and eye-catching athleticism. This dominance made her a sought-after star, landing her opportunities that spanned from mainstay feuds in AEW to future ventures in WWE. Despite minimal prior experience, she found ways to make each televised match a statement piece, proving that a fresh face can become a marquee attraction if booked effectively.
In WWE, Solo Sikoa gained rapid momentum as Roman Reigns’s enforcer in The Bloodline. He began as an intimidating presence but soon stepped into a bigger spotlight. By 2024, he had begun carving out his own identity, even hinting at rivalries with members of his own faction. The tension within The Bloodline showed how quickly allegiances can shift and how a star’s role can expand if the storyline resonates with audiences. Meanwhile, Carmelo Hayes made waves in NXT, adopting the moniker “Him” and showing that top-tier ring work, flair on the microphone, and confidence can attract fans in a developmental brand. Hayes then crossed into bigger shows, suggesting that his talents could soon command main-roster attention.
Each of these success stories highlights the interplay of booking, raw potential, and audience engagement. Good storytelling and consistent performance can accelerate a star’s rise, transforming them from promising rookies to legitimate challengers for major titles.
Potential Breakout Stars for 2025
As we settle into a new year, several wrestlers are poised to become the next Mariah May, Solo Sikoa, or Carmelo Hayes. Though their backgrounds and styles differ, they share a hunger to grab the spotlight and define the future of professional wrestling. The following individuals stand out for their ring prowess, character development, and ability to captivate audiences on a large scale, representing the top breakout stars in WWE and AEW fans should keep an eye on.
Stephanie Vaquer (WWE)
Stephanie Vaquer brings a unique background to WWE, having already showcased her skill in CMLL and NJPW. Her global experience has honed her technical proficiency, which she now blends with a keen sense of showmanship. While her English promos are still evolving, Vaquer’s in-ring approach could override any language barriers, much like Asuka did upon arrival in NXT. She’s shown a flair for creative offense and strong fundamentals, and word around the wrestling world is that she’s on WWE’s radar for a more prominent push. If she’s given the right storylines and any measure of creative freedom, expect her to dazzle crowds who are eager to rally behind the next big name. By the close of this year, Vaquer may well become a household name, especially if she seizes a high-stakes title match that cements her place in WWE’s women’s division.
Trick Williams (WWE)
Trick Williams embodies the phrase “charisma personified.” In NXT, he progressed from sidekick status to capturing championships and generating loud reactions whenever he wrestles. Fans chant “Whoop that trick!” in a natural show of support. Many believe he has the athletic ability and star power to thrive on Raw or SmackDown. Not only can he hold his own in the ring against seasoned veterans, but he also has a dynamic personality that plays well in larger arenas. If creative continues to lean into his strengths, it’s easy to imagine Williams entering main-roster feuds that boost him to a possible Intercontinental or United States Championship reign in the coming months.
Ludwig Kaiser (WWE)
Ludwig Kaiser has quietly stepped out of Gunther’s shadow, beginning to cultivate a persona that blends cunning villainy with refined poise. His work with the Imperium stable showcased his discipline, but it was when he started pursuing singles opportunities that fans began seeing his true range. He nearly captured the Intercontinental Championship, proving that he’s more than a mere henchman. This year could be pivotal. If Kaiser remains on his trajectory and further polishes his on-screen presence, he could evolve into one of the most engaging antagonists in WWE. He has the foundation to become an Intercontinental Champion, and if his angles are compelling, he might even vie for higher honors.
Tiffany Stratton (WWE)
When Tiffany Stratton first appeared, some viewers shrugged her off as a one-dimensional “spoiled socialite.” She soon impressed people with her athletic prowess, fluid ring movement, and a knack for connecting with crowds. By 2024, she had won the Money in the Bank contract, signaling WWE’s faith in her potential. Then, she made an even bolder statement on the very first SmackDown of 2025, claiming the WWE Women’s Championship in a thrilling upset victory. This landmark win left no doubt about her rise as a main-event competitor. Her ability to adapt her persona from lighthearted antagonism to serious contender underscores her versatility in WWE programming. With the championship now around her waist, Stratton looks ready to confront anyone in the women’s division—from established giants like Charlotte Flair to fellow up-and-comers seeking a breakout moment of their own. Expect her to use her newfound gold to keep pushing boundaries, redefine her image, and reshape WWE’s women’s division in the coming months.
Solo Sikoa (WWE)
Although Solo Sikoa already feels like a top-tier star, there’s room for further growth. He spent 2024 establishing himself as a dangerous force capable of challenging Roman Reigns for leadership of The Bloodline. This storyline has the potential to become an era-defining feud in WWE. A direct showdown with Reigns could transform Sikoa from a powerful supporter into a central leading figure on SmackDown. Fans are eager to see whether he can maintain that sense of intimidation while stepping out from his cousin’s shadow. If the booking keeps him strong, this could be the year Sikoa fully embraces a main-event position, possibly securing a major title and altering the faction’s hierarchy forever.
Daniel Garcia (AEW)
Daniel Garcia has all the tools to become one of AEW’s pillars: technical ability, stamina, and an earnest passion for wrestling. In matches against Bryan Danielson and Will Ospreay, he proved he can compete with the industry’s best and produce show-stealing performances. The only barrier is inconsistent creative focus, as start-stop pushes sometimes hinder him. If AEW decides to showcase him in a sustained storyline—perhaps a lengthy pursuit of the TNT Championship or even a rivalry with MJF—Garcia might finally claim the spotlight. He’s an in-ring technician who can make any bout look like a genuine struggle for victory, an attribute that resonates with fans craving realism in professional wrestling.
Konosuke Takeshita (AEW)
Japanese standout Konosuke Takeshita has impressed fans with his explosive strikes and commanding presence. His matches are crisp, with well-timed moments that can bring a live crowd to its feet. Yet despite rave reviews, he hasn’t enjoyed a consistent push that rockets him toward a major title for more than a few weeks at a time. If AEW’s booking team decides to give him a meaningful storyline—perhaps tying him to Don Callis’s manipulations or placing him on a path to an AEW title—Takeshita could become one of the promotion’s biggest international stars. His ability to mesh with various wrestling styles also means he could shine in crossover events or special matches against visiting NJPW talents.
Hook (AEW)
Hook carries the legacy of his father, Taz, and has developed a cool mystique thanks to his understated demeanor. He isn’t a loud, boisterous personality, but fans have gravitated to him precisely because of his calm intensity and real-life fighting style. Pairing him with Samoa Joe and Chris Jericho has introduced him to mainstream AEW viewers. The question is whether the company will give him stories that allow him to show additional dimensions of his character, from comedic timing to emotional depth. If they do, he might climb up from the mid-card to become a more formidable challenger in the TNT or AEW World Championship scenes. By year’s end, Hook could be a central figure if his presence continues to resonate with fans.
Willow Nightingale (AEW)
Willow Nightingale stands out as a true babyface who radiates positivity every time she walks through the curtain. Her bright smile and bubbly aura might fool some into thinking she’s gentle in the ring, but she actually hits hard and displays fierce determination. Feuds with Mercedes Moné elevated her profile, showing she can hold her own against well-established names. AEW, facing constant calls for more substantial women’s storylines, might rely on Nightingale’s popularity to anchor feuds and fill main-event spots on Dynamite or pay-per-views. If the creative team capitalizes on her sympathetic underdog appeal, Willow could secure her spot as a Women’s World Champion in the near future.
Mariah May (AEW)
Mariah May’s trajectory has mirrored that of many breakout stars who start off tied to bigger names, only to emerge with their own identity. She began as someone who idolized Toni Storm, then moved into a storyline that showcased her personal growth and in-ring prowess. Audiences responded well, especially as they saw glimpses of her versatility—whether playing the devoted sidekick or turning on her mentor to chase singles success. If AEW leverages this storyline foundation to vault May into a major title picture, she might surprise some fans by winning matches over seasoned opponents. Her creativity, tenacity, and ability to adapt will be critical to how far she can go this year.
Factors Behind Breakout Potential
A significant element behind any wrestler’s ascent is the creative direction of their promotion. WWE often reboots its storylines, presenting brand splits, changing champions, or introducing new factions. These shifts can create opportunities for hidden gems, but they can also bury someone who lacks momentum at the time of change. AEW, with its more flexible booking, tries to capitalize on real-life scenarios, forging collaborative matches with other promotions. This arrangement can fast-track stars like Takeshita, who have global recognition and can shine in dream matches broadcast to both Western and Eastern audiences.
Social media engagement also shapes success. A wrestler who can spark viral moments—through a promotional appearance, online banter, or a meme-worthy in-ring sequence—might see increased merchandise sales and greater fan support. Young stars with a knack for entertaining fans across Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube build their brands faster than ever. In contrast, wrestlers who struggle with publicity can remain underexposed, even if they excel in the ring.
Another factor is the evolving tastes of wrestling fans. Today’s audience appreciates wrestlers with diverse backgrounds, distinct styles, and authentic voices. Performers who represent their cultures authentically often connect more strongly with new and existing audiences. Additionally, fans continue to demand better representation and deeper storylines in women’s divisions. As promotions answer that demand, stars like Tiffany Stratton and Stephanie Vaquer may benefit from more robust creative support. Stratton’s victory at the start of 2025 confirms WWE’s seriousness about spotlighting newer faces, a trend that could keep fueling these divisions.
Challenges on the Road to Stardom
One major stumbling block on the path to a breakout is injury. Pro wrestlers take risks that can lead to extended time on the sidelines. Injuries often halt a performer’s momentum, forcing them to rebuild upon returning. Dante Martin from AEW experienced this setback: after impressing fans with his aerial skills, he suffered a serious leg injury and lost his upward trajectory. Overcoming such hurdles requires not only physical recovery but also narrative recalibration, as creative teams must find new ways to reintegrate a returning star.
Another challenge is roster competition. With so many emerging talents, it’s easy for even skilled performers to get stuck in short feuds or be used sparingly on secondary shows. Austin Theory went through a period when he was overshadowed by other WWE storylines and stars, taking a step back after initially appearing poised to conquer the company’s mid-card. In AEW, a similar dynamic occasionally derails those who don’t land a consistent storyline across Dynamite, Rampage, or pay-per-views.
It can also be risky to push a character too quickly, as fans might react negatively if they sense that someone is being forced into top-tier positions without organically earning them. Balancing hype and authenticity is critical. Sometimes a slow-burn storyline allows a wrestler’s strengths to bloom, rather than a sudden mega-push that lacks substance. Talent, booking, and timing must align for the perfect breakout moment.
The Impact of Breakout Stars
When a wrestler catches fire, the promotion benefits. New stars mean fresh feuds, heightened interest from both hardcore fans and casual viewers, and an infusion of excitement into weekly programming. In the short term, a breakout star might challenge established veterans, fueling intense rivalries that galvanize pay-per-view buy rates and TV ratings. Over a longer period, successful up-and-comers become anchors of the brand. They sell merchandise, represent their company at press events, and inspire younger performers to aim higher. In some instances, breakout wrestlers transcend wrestling itself, appearing in movies or mainstream media segments, further boosting the promotion’s visibility.
A prime example is how AEW capitalized on Hook’s early hype or how WWE relied on NXT success stories to fill main-event gaps when top veterans took hiatuses. The overall landscape shifts whenever new stars become pillars of the roster. In a business that thrives on continuous renewal, these new faces ensure that storylines don’t become stagnant. Each breakout star adds new possibilities for alliances, betrayals, and championship battles.
The Future of Wrestling Stardom
Professional wrestling thrives on transformation and renewal. Whether it’s at a Monday Night Raw, a SmackDown taping, or a major AEW pay-per-view, every show offers a platform for new talents to shine. As 2025 gets underway, the scene has already changed. Tiffany Stratton’s triumph on the first SmackDown of the year validated the excitement surrounding her, while stars like Stephanie Vaquer, Trick Williams, and Ludwig Kaiser wait for storylines that could catapult them further. On the AEW side, Daniel Garcia and Konosuke Takeshita are prime examples of technical wizards who can captivate both hardcore fans and newcomers. Hook maintains a mystique that sets him apart, and Willow Nightingale’s joyous spirit could elevate her to the top of the women’s ranks. Mariah May remains a prime candidate to eclipse even her mentor’s legacy.
Ultimately, the wrestling world remains unpredictable. Title changes, surprising signings, and unexpected injuries will shape the road ahead. However, the individuals spotlighted here have exhibited the right blend of talent, timing, and fan engagement, indicating that their greatest achievements lie just around the corner. As the year progresses, fans should prepare for potential shake-ups, enthralling rivalries, and unforgettable moments of triumph.
These top breakout stars in WWE and AEW stand on the brink of breakout glory. Their stories encapsulate what makes pro wrestling thrilling: the potential for transformation at any moment, the mixture of athletic skill and dramatic flair, and the sheer excitement of seeing who will step up to claim the crown. By staying adaptable, creative, and in sync with the pulse of the audience, they can carve out legacies that keep fans talking far beyond 2025. If the past few seasons are any indication, the future of WWE, AEW, and the entire wrestling landscape is blazing bright—and the talented men and women listed here will be at the forefront of that dazzling dawn.
Leave a Reply